With one day left of the George W. Bush era, the obvious question presents itself… Is he the worst president ever?
In my opinion, he just gets the bronze medal. He’s the third worst.
Don’t get me wrong, he’s been a gigantic disaster of almost unimaginable proportions. Fiscally, the debt he’s generated is unparalleled in peacetime. Internationally, he’s dragged our reputation from sky-high to sewer-low. Morally, he’s stained us forever by institutionalizing torture. There’s no question that he’s been reckless, irresponsible and… in some ways most awful of all… massively incompetent.
Nonetheless, in our short history as a nation, there have been two leaders even worse.
Number two is a choice that many will find surprising: John Adams (1797-1801). Adams was a patriot and a critical revolutionary leader, instrumental to the birth of the republic. But his presidency was marred by the Alien and Sedition Acts, legislation that was so horrendous it almost killed everything important about the country, in it’s infancy. At a time when American democracy was weak and vulnerable, the Acts gave the federal government the power to jail its critics. Had they not been immediately repealed, the First Amendment would have been gutted and our most important freedoms squashed. America and the world would have been far darker. Historians make many excuses for Adams: He was forced to sign the Acts by his party, he was trying to avoid war with France, the country really was at risk of civil war. But Adams had a responsibility to nurture and protect the fledgling Constitution. He failed in the most fundamental way and that can never be forgiven.
My choice for number one is much more orthodox: James Buchanan (1857-1861). He tops almost every list! He stood by while the South seceded, setting the stage for the bloody Civil War that killed more Americans than any other conflict and almost destroyed the nation. It took the preternatural wisdom and strength of Lincoln (unquestionably our best president) to save it.
George W. Bush was a disaster… But he wasn’t quite in that league!
Share on Facebook and other services:
Politics
George W. Bush, James Buchanan, John Adams, Worst Presdients Ever